September 20, 2008

We’re Not Press, but WAR *is* Everywhere!

It’s not like we didn’t see this coming.  Right now, in this little slice of the blogosphere, the launch of Warhammer Online has turned blogger against blogger, with the Warhammer enthusiasts facing off against, well, anyone who isn’t a Warhammer enthusiast.  It’s the blogosphere version of RvR, only there are no squigs and no living cities.  (Plenty of Waaagh though).

I remember a long discussion that my “Shut Up We’re Talking” Common Sense co-host Darren started about whether bloggers are press.  Lately, the answer seems to be a resounding NO.  The main job of the “press,” is dissemination of information.  Yes, bloggers can help generate interest in a game, but journalistic credibility evaporates when the focus becomes “them.”  And while it’s true that commentary can fall under the definition of “press,” there is a fine line between insightful analysis and slightly longer versions of mundane forum replies.

The recent interview of Erling Ellingsen by Daedren of MMOCrunch is one example of that blurring line between journalism and ownzj00 forum flaming.  What should have been a newsworthy and timely interview of AoC’s Product Manager instead turned into a piece largely about Daedren.  His original review of Age of Conan was important, because whether one agrees with it or not, it presented a thorough recap all things wrong with the game.  But he did himself a disservice when he forgot that it was the review, and not him, that readers found newsworthy.  As soon as he inserted himself into the equation, credibility was lost, and the result was a Jerry Springer-esque feel to the interview, rather than a professional tone that might have helped to push forward the discussion of AoC’s troubles.

There was also a certain weirdness to the whole revelation of Tobold getting a lifetime subscription to Warhammer Online.  Tobold is definitely an established blogger, with a prolific entry count, and a plump readership.  But when he made the announcement that he accepted a lifetime subscription, it made for a very awkward moment.  What’s the point of A) taking a subscription that he probably won’t use much at all and B) making it newsworthy by devoting an entire blog entry to it.  With the title, “Full Disclosure on my Relationship with Mythic,” it’s little surprise that Tobold, the Blogger, was the focus of the debate.  Right on cue, the blogosphere abided, and Toboldgate was born.

And in the past few days, we’ve become witness to a tag team blog-off about Warhammer Online that included references to Kool-Aid, Communist Russia, and the Bible.  I don’t necessarily endorse the beehive-prodding strategy of Tipa (although her recent entries are hilarious and have become the only sparkling gem that’s emerged from this showdown), and I also disagree with going so far as to start a crusade against Warhammer fans.  But at the same time, it’s slightly ridiculous that the same people over and over are making it personal, and rejecting any thoughtful criticism about this particular game.

Tipa wrote an entry a while back that still rings in my head from time to time.  She threw down the gauntlet, and challenged the blogosphere to roll up their sleeves, dive into a game, stick with it for a year, and write about it.  Not write about press releases, developer videos, and breathless anticipation of future titles, but about what exactly we are doing nightly when we log in to the game of our choice.  That’s something that I used to do regularly, and something that I have had trouble doing of late.  I agree with her that we don’t see enough of that, and it’s too bad, because that’s when blogger personalities are a welcome part of the writing process, and, if done well, really improve the quality of the storytelling.  Tipa, Stargrace, and Van Hemlock are just three bloggers who do it well, and make me wish I could get back into that groove again.

Over in my guild, I’ve made it our philosophy that if someone has visions of their toon’s name, lit up with flashing bulbs that become so bright they explode into flames because the name is so powerful, they probably should look elsewhere for a home.  I think the same should go for blogging.  I’ve never had any aspirations of this blog becoming anything newsworthy, and I also don’t consider myself press.  But to those that might, it’s worth noting that it’s the games, and what happens in those games, that’s newsworthy.

Posted by jayernh under Archive,Gaming Commentary | Comments (8)

8 Comments »

  1. You have just violated the rules of the interwebs by making too much sense and you shall be punished accordingly.

    Jason (resident drunken idiot of Channel Massive)

    Comment by Jason — September 20, 2008 @ 7:25 pm

  2. Impressive post.
    Nicely said and as Jason said…

    Too much sense…crazy!

    Comment by Openedge1 — September 20, 2008 @ 8:33 pm

  3. [...] I just read Jaye’s latest post over at Journeys with Jaye, and it got me thinking about the writing I’ve been doing here at Random Battle. The focus of this blog has never been very much about my personal gaming sessions, but I also don’t consider this a hard news blog. I’m certainly not posting for every bit of newsworthy information that comes my way. [...]

    Pingback by Why Do You Read Random Battle? | Random Battle — September 20, 2008 @ 9:51 pm

  4. Doh. Whatever the first two said.

    In addition to that, I will stick with the games I play and report my -and my brothers’- mishaps whenever there is reason to do so. But I will also include some thinking over how things could be, to what it all relates to and how the heck did we get here. Well, the last part is up to each and everyone by themselves, but about the other things I’ll be blogging.

    Oh yes, and the hounds.

    Comment by Copra — September 23, 2008 @ 3:00 am

  5. [...] Wait, I’m in the “News” department?  Am I press?  Ha Ha! [...]

    Pingback by Slow News Day… « The Ancient Gaming Noob — September 23, 2008 @ 2:10 pm

  6. Hi, I’m Daedren. ;)

    The article was originally published on my own personal site: http://www.r1ft.com

    Keep in mind this interview was spawned solely because of the “Post Mortem Analysis” I did on Age of Conan. A certain backstory is then required.

    Anyway, my “Jerry Springer-esque” style (though I prefer the Howard Stern that some readers give me) is my style. If you don’t like it, that’s fair – but calling it a “disservice” is just plain wrong. I got straight to the point and asked the questions no one else has. Your interpretation of me self-praising or making the article about me was not my intent and I honestly don’t see it that way.

    To each their own, I suppose. ;)

    – Daedren

    Comment by Daedren — September 24, 2008 @ 4:34 am

  7. [...] The Age of Commenting Tipa salutes her new Communist overlord “If there’s one thing I’ve learned in my two years of blogging, it’s that you need a thick skin.” Openedge1 has a few choice words for some fellow bloggers Naturally, Journeys With Jaye is the only sane blogger alive…    Episode 60 – Start Wreck: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download [...]

    Pingback by Channel Massive » Blog Archive » Episode 60 - Start Wreck — October 2, 2008 @ 3:48 pm

  8. bouncy castle…

    Tyrian Express: September 2008…

    Trackback by bouncy castle — July 8, 2014 @ 6:21 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. | Trackback: http://www.journeyswithjaye.com/wordpress/wp-trackback.php?p=1365

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.